Log in

No account? Create an account

May 22nd, 2011

Let me use the occasion of failed eschatology to rant (again) against the SF end-timers. Oh, if only a spiritual being like Carl Sagan had seen and effectively expressed the total meaning of his revelations.

I have characterized (in the manner of an apostate) hard science fiction as literature about Man’s noble quest for new sources of minerals to mine. Such a literature is bad enough, but there is also an end-time mythology, in which an asteroid strike, let’s say, wipes out the home planet; fine so far, because such a strike really could happen and really could wipe out our living conditions. But what lesson do the eschatologists draw from their revelation? That we ought to expand our population into space so that when the end times come there will be a remnant of the human race that can start over again.

In a variant eschatology, instead of an asteroid strike there is the general trashing of the Earth by humankind, with the bulk of the human race living in misery upon the home planet, and a tiny few living a difficult but noble life among the planets – searching, of course, for new ores. We may recognize here the works, for instance, of Ben Bova.

I hope the resemblance of the SF eschatologies to notorious Christian ones is evident. Not that I expect the SF eschatologists to take their concerns so seriously that they sell everything, put up billboards, and hand out leaflets.

The central flaw in the SF worldviews here lambasted is that they put the value of ‘the human race’, which is a verbal abstraction, above the value of people, who are not words. They are people, dammit. They might as well be Martians, because what matters is that they are people. What is the point of saving a remnant of the human race so that we can say ‘humans’ still exist, if we let billions of living individuals suffer and die on an abandoned world?

If the bulk of the world’s population is not to be ‘saved’ with no special initiation on their own part, then neither a religion nor a literature that takes itself seriously is worth following.

My tweets

  • Sat, 14:21: Latest tweet on @EBibleFellowshp is an excerpt from the KJV about waiting on seemingly failed prophecy. I recommend the new JPS on this one.
  • Sat, 14:39: I think @inthatday is trying to say that the Rapture is still going to happen today, but at midnight Jerusalem time.
  • Sat, 14:50: Here we go, this site has an active countdown to midnight in Jerusalem: http://truthuunsealed.blogspot.com/ This is the new formulation.
  • Sat, 16:07: Two minutes after the new Rapture calculation fails, @conservTrump tweets about the Wisconsin Senate race.
  • Sat, 17:35: RT @mom2two2330: @joymcgill wow...i really feel for the people who believed & gave everything away & quit their jobs. #rapturefail
  • Sat, 17:35: RT @joymcgill: My grandfather had friend in 1920s who only completed 5th grade b/c family felt rapture happening soon & no need for educ ...
  • Sat, 17:59: 5:59 local time here, and I am looking for an apocalypse. (Keep in mind that an "apocalypse" means a revelation.)
  • Sat, 18:00: 6:00 pm here in Minneapolis-St Paul, but all the fun today is in Iceland.
  • Sat, 18:33: Following the #rapturefail but looked out the window and there were people in the air. But they wore black & were sitting on brooms ...
  • Sat, 19:14: ‘Words spoken softly by wise men are heeded sooner than those shouted by a lord in folly.’ Ecc. 9-17
Read more...Collapse )


Latest Month

June 2016


  • 25 Mar 2014, 01:22
    In case it matters, the most recent confirmed lahar is about 500 years ago, but there were mixed reports of eruptions in the late 1800s.
  • 25 Mar 2014, 01:20
    Pretty low until you jinxed them.
  • 25 Mar 2014, 01:01
    What would you estimate the odds to be of it happening in the next 200 years?
  • 27 Jan 2014, 06:22
    Thinking about it further, I think I now understand. You're saying the WSJ is being antisemitic, not the people they're quoting.

    I don't think they'd listen to it coming from us, but a…
  • 27 Jan 2014, 06:09
    I'm not noticing it either. Seems to me they *are* being assholes to Jews, but only moreso than anybody else if we happen to be in the way. I think that's gneral-purpose assholery, not…
Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by yoksel